When
I was first told of a Cirque du Soleil tribute to Elvis Presley, I thought,
Hey! That’s not a bad idea! After all, Cirque du Soleil was responsible for
the huge extravaganza that was The Beatles Love. It seemed
only logical that the King of Rock would be a topic worthy of their talent and
hard work. If not for the influence of Presley there is a good chance that the
Beatles might never even have existed. At the very least their music would not
have sounded anything like what it did.
Not only did he provide a muse for the Fab Four, by that time he’d already
opened the ears of “the kids” to rock and roll music (a feat that
earned him much scorn from parents of those same kids). Too many people in this
day and age have ho idea why Elvis is “The King”. A good part of it
is because he was one of the first artists to successfully introduce black music
to the white man. Sounds absurd, doesn’t it? A relic from the days of segregation
and, unpalatable as it certainly is to consider, that was the state of affairs
in the 50s when Elvis first began recording. In light of that, it doesn’t really
matter how many records the man has sold (and/or still sells, post-mortem).
It’s what he has already DONE that counts. That’s why he’s afforded regal status.
Which is probably for the best…or WAS, I should say. Eventually even his
own performances descended into mediocrity in his final years. His core audience
had been reduced to vacationing housewives looking to re-live the “good
old days”. You can kind of see how his music lost a lot of its relevance.
Is Viva Elvis an attempt to bring some of that relevance back?
Or is it justanother nostalgic “Those were the Days” free-for-all
geared at reaching the folks in Vegas who he catered to during his final years?
A little bit of both, I say. With both successes and failures on both fronts.
If you go into Viva Elvis hoping for the same ingenious magic
that was evident in The Beatles Love, you will be disappointed.
I want to say “sorely disappointed.” but that tag would only apply
if you were expecting a similar mash-up style implemented on the Love
show. If you aren’t familiar with what a “mash-up” is, don’t
worry. It’s not exactly a household word. A “mash-up” is a
musical composition which incorporates at least two song elements that fit well
together (hence, “mashed up”). Usually more than one band/artist
is featured in any given mash-up, but this isn’t always the case. I’ve
got one in my collection that mixes and matches the Beatles’ “I
Am The Walrus” and “Ball of Confusion” by the Temptations.
If you’d never heard the original songs individually you’d never
know there were two instead of one (does that make sense, even?). Actually,
Beatles mash-ups aren’t all too hard to find on the Internet. But Love
kicked it up several notches by virtue of sound quality alone. That’s
not even counting the fact that the sequencing is more creative and extensive
than what you’ll ever download from a music blog. Love is one huge, marvelous
mash-up with stellar production…which is what you WON’T be getting
with Viva Elvis. No doubt part of this is because the man was
a SINGER…his talents didn’t extend to writing the music he was singing
to. Besides, that stuff’s so DATED, right? Apparently the Viva
Elvis people thought so, because the most obvious thing about the album
is how “fleshed out” the arrangements are. Not only is the overall
SOUND ratcheted up, even whole chord structures are modified.
It’s not necessarily a bad idea. Somewhat jarring, though, when you’ve
grown up with the actual Elvis songs. Still, Presley’s voice, given a
digital polishing, sounds better than ever, even if it IS floating on top of
music that was recorded in a studio 100 times more advanced than any he ever
actually recorded in. Hearing all this gloss and sheen I found myself missing
the barebones quality of the arcane Sun sessions. I couldn’t help but
think that there was no way Viva Elvis could get to those of
us who believe his career as a legitimate rock and roll star ended on the day
he enlisted in the service. Perhaps it’s for the dying breed of “Elvis
could do no wrong” fanatics who will snatch up any and everything even
remotely associated with the man. Or maybe it’s meant to be a cool souvenir
to help you relive an exciting evening spent with Cirque du Soleil. And it’s
obvious that the label hopes to bring some younger listeners into the Presley
fold. I mean, come on! They’ve even got DJ Pocket on board to scratch
some vinyl. What’s that you say? Who the hell is DJ Pocket?
Bottom line for me, despite any intentions on the part of the label, I just
don’t know. The thing is an enigma to me. The concept, I accept, is a
clever one. But what it all boils down to is this: Viva Elvis
is a novelty record. My tolerance for novelty records is pretty low and this
one, though very well done, is just that. Without the accompanying visuals in
the stage show it’s kind of hard to really get a feel for what is actually
going on here. Some of the sequences and sampled voice clips are downright bizarre
when excised from the visuals. A perfect example can be heard in the first two
minutes of the record. It’s an introduction, of sorts, filled with the
sound of rabid female Elvis fans loudly expressing their devotion, the majestic
strains of “Also Sprach Zarathustra” (also known is some parts of
the south as “Elvis’ Theme Song”) and a host of other semi-related
sound bytes. A heavy bossa nova beat descends into the maelstrom and competes
with the Strauss piece for rhythmic domination. Not too sure which wins, but
it didn’t sound like either was doing what it meant to be doing. The two
wildly differing styles battle it out for almost two minutes. TWO MINUTES! Get
on with it, brotha.
This all leads to a chopped up version of “Blue Suede Shoes.” You
may actually find yourself wishing the intro was even longer when you hear this
rendition. One of the coolest things about “Blue Suede Shoes” is
in how the music breaks for the vocals with each line (similar to what he did
with “Heartbreak Hotel,” which is also presented in mind boggling
fashion on Viva Elvis). Well that’s all been re-arranged
for this version. The pulsing bass and drums flow monotonously through the whole
song. All of the music (save bass and drum) is practically stripped from the
song and when guitars finally do come around they sound more like U2’s
“Desire” than anything resembling the actual song.
Elvis Presley Enterprises signed off on this whole mess. I have to wonder what
Elvis himself would have thought of how this song has been butchered? I won’t
presume to speak for the dead, but were it my opinion being solicited I’d
have to say that the first order of business at the next board meeting would
be all about filling the empty seats left vacant, unwillingly, as a direct result
of letting this tune get trampled on so hard.
Okay, so that’s pretty harsh. I admit there are a couple of nice sections
scattered throughout the CD’s 42- minute duration. “Burning Love,”
for instance, lends itself particularly well to a modern re-make. It at least
has that going for it. Yet it’s barely enough to save the tune from the
reconstructed chord changes. This chord mangling is pervasive in all of the
songs presented here. It’s almost as if the people responsible for Viva
Elvis just didn’t like the original chords and decided it would be better
to throw in a few of their own.
More strangeness ensues. Can you imagine “That’s All Right”
set to a musical hybrid of David Gray and Jet? As far as I’m concerned
the end result sounds tailor made for an annoying television commercial.
The pre-release publicity for this album seemed to place no small amount of
significance on the fact that Brendan O’Brien produced three of the 12
tracks on the record. “That’s All Right” was the first of
that trio. I’m not gonna knock O’Brien. He’s done very well
for Pearl Jam. So what if I was disappointed in the two albums he cut with Bruce
Springsteen? None of that makes a hill-of-beans as far as Viva Elvis
is concerned. Fact is that the songs he worked on here are quite indiscernible
from those the other producers did. BIG names like Serban Ghenea, Robert Meunier
and Erich van Tourneau. I guess they’re big names, I don’t know.
Just because I’ve never heard of them certainly doesn’t mean they
aren’t big names.
“Love Me Tender” and “Can’t Help Falling in Love”
are both done up as duets with Dea Norberg and Sherry St. Germain, respectively.
More big names. Both of these ladies could probably hold their own with the
American Idol set, but they’ll never be mistaken for Aretha Franklin.
The third of the Brenden O’Brien tracks, and the finale to the disc, is
“Suspicious Minds.” It starts out quite promising. I guess it HAS
to, since this one could well be considered the peak of Elvis Presley’s
recording career. It’s a well-loved song. It’s a great song, no
other way to put it. It’s hard to screw up such a classic song. Good thing
O’Brien’s on top of things. Sounds awesome the first couple of minutes,
like I’d hoped the whole album would. Elvis’ voice is powerful enough
to raise some goose bumps and for once the instrumental music seems perfectly
fitted to the part. An almost haunting sound that merges with a heavily processed
guitar. You might even mistake it for the signature style of U2’s axe
man The Edge. It’s a sound he has honed and milked over the course of
25+ years. It’s wisely pulled back on “Suspicious Minds” to
make way, one would assume, for Presley’s priceless voice. Everything
moves along smoothly, even beautifully. It does, that is, until the 1:35 time
marker comes around, at which point the mood is totally destroyed by the entrance
of the garage band who practice down the street from where you live. With only
a brief respite the rockers come back and don’t leave until the song is
over. Makes me want to drag out the original and listen to it just to get the
bad taste out of my ears.
I’ve raked this record over the coals, I realize. And to be honest, that
kind of bugs me. I want SO MUCH to like “Viva Elvis” – or perhaps
I mean “what I thought it could have been.” It teases just enough
to make you think, “Wait a minute!
This ain’t so bad after all!” But then something comes along so
wretched that you wonder how you came to the conclusion that it could possibly
be redeemed in the first place.
Of course, I’m looking at it (listening to it) as if it were a typical
CD release, not even thinking about the Cirque du Soleil aspect. That’s
an important facet, too, because the one thing I can tell you with certainty
is that Viva Elvis is, at its core, a SOUNDTRACK album. I don’t
see it as being considered as much more than that. That’s how it comes
across. Were I to experience the Cirque du Soleil event, I would no doubt buy
a copy at the merchandise stand. But the only reason for purchasing it would
be to remember the show itself. I’d probably never listen to it again.
If times really got tough it would be one of the first discs in my collection
to be sacrificed to the weird dude behind the counter at the used CD store.
